Semrush Hero Banner

Etsy vs Shopify: An In-Depth Showdown for Savvy Sellers

Etsy vs Shopify: An In-Depth Showdown for Savvy Sellers

Do-it-yourself virtual shopping has been on the rise, and you are probably reading this because you want to get a piece of that online pie. Nowadays, it is advisable for any person with something to sell, whether a wise creator or a vintage dealer, to establish their internet market.

So what should you do first? With many platforms, it can take time to identify the right one for your case. Do not worry, my friend; herein, we will delve deeper into two major players in the industry: Etsy vs Shopify.

Please make yourself comfortable, take some homemade snacks (preferably made by hand), and let's kick off this party before we begin.

Etsy: The OG Handmade Marketplace

How To Sell Your Art On Etsy

Etsy is an online marketplace for DIY enthusiasts. It has been referred to as the place for people searching for unique, handmade and vintage products. If it is a one-off item that screams individuality, you'll likely find it on Etsy.

Etsy by Numbers

Created in 2005, making it one of the oldest sites where people sell things online

Around 100 million buyers will be actively purchasing goods (by 2023)

There are over 7.4 million sellers who are currently selling products on Etsy (2022 Data)

In 2022, there was $5.6 billion worth of sales made through Etsy — this number reflects gross merchandise sales (the total value of goods sold through the site)

Impressive numbers, but that's not all!

The Good Sides of Using Etsy

  1. Ready-made customers: The site draws millions of shoppers daily, so an audience is already waiting for what you have to sell.
  2. Quality control: Etsy appraises each vendor and their items individually, ensuring that everything meets specific standards while being original.
  3. Like-minded community: Sellers can participate in forums or even attend meetups organised by other sellers, fostering friendships among creators with similar interests or challenges.
  4. Simple start-up process: Even someone with minimal technical skills can set up shop quickly because getting started on this platform does not require much technology knowledge.
👉 Read More:  Top 10 Best SEO Tools Every Marketer Should Be Using

The Bad Sides of Using Etsy

  1. Expensive fees: Listing and transaction fees mean that using the platform can become very costly, particularly if cost management isn't taken seriously when calculating profits realised from sales made using this website.
  2. Too many competitors: Millions of all clamouring for attention may drown out your unique voice if it is deafening!
  3. Generic templates: While options are available, they may not be what you're looking for if you want something more customised, limiting how far branding efforts can go beyond basic customisation options such as colour schemes or logo placements.
  4. Limited range of products: Etsy does not allow certain items to be sold on their platform, so there might be restrictions on what can and cannot be offered here.

Shopify: The Ecommerce Powerhouse

Shopify Signup Page

While Etsy focuses on handmade and vintage goods, Shopify is a versatile e-commerce platform that can sell almost anything under the sun. You name it, from physical products to digital downloads, subscriptions to services.

Shopify in Numbers

Launched in 2004, making it a seasoned veteran as well

Over 4.8 million active websites

$200 billion in gross merchandise volume in 2022

Empowers more than 1.8 million businesses across 175 countries

Well, that's quite the heavyweight!

Pros of Shopify

  1. Flexibility: You can customise your online store in many different ways with Shopify to reflect your brand identity.
  2. Scalability: Shopify grows alongside your business by providing advanced features and integrations needed for expansion.
  3. Rich features: Inventory management, shipping solutions – you name it; this platform covers everything.
  4. Mobile optimisation: Your site will automatically adjust according to the device visitors use for an uninterrupted browsing experience while on the go.

Cons of Shopify

  1. Cost: Although various pricing plans are available through Shopify – especially when considering more significant enterprises – some other e-commerce platforms might appear cheaper.
  2. Learning curve: Setting up and customising a store with Shopify can be more involved than what's required on Etsy; this entails specific technical skills or patience while learning them from scratch.
  3. No built-in audience: Unlike Etsy, where sellers tap into existing customer base immediately after signing up, here, one has no choice but to work hard towards generating traffic independently, which eventually leads to conversions within their respective stores hosted by this particular provider called ‘Shopify'.
  4. Transaction fees: Though transparent about its pricing structure overall, external payment gateways attract additional charges vis-à-vis transactions made through them.

Head-to-Head: Etsy vs Shopify

Lezada Shopify Theme Min

Now that we have the basics down, let's dive into the nitty-gritty and see how these two ecommerce giants compare.

Ease of Use

Etsy: Super Simple for Starters

Among many things, Etsy is well known for being user-friendly. Creating your shop is a piece of cake, thanks to its easy onboarding process and intuitive dashboard. Even if you're not tech-savvy, don't worry; you should be able to navigate through Etsy without much trouble.

Shopify: A Bit More Complicated

On the flip side, Shopify requires extra upfront effort from you. Though still reasonably straightforward overall, you'll need to roll up your sleeves and get familiar with the different features and customisation options available on the platform. It's better than it seems! Shopify offers plenty of resources and support along the way.

👉 Read More:  The 100 Most Famous Logos of All-Time

Product Offerings

Etsy: Handmade Heaven

As mentioned earlier, Etsy specialises in handmade, vintage, and artisanal items. If you're a maker or vintage seller (or anything similar), Etsy is where you belong! Just remember that if what you sell isn't handmade or mass-produced… Well, sorry, buddy — this isn't work for you (try Shopify!).

Shopify: Anything You Want It To Be

With Shopify, there are no limits regarding what products can be sold through their system. Whether physical goods are involved or digital downloads are being peddled, whether services are rendered or even subscriptions are offered — let me tell you right now: Shopify has everything under control! This makes them an ideal choice for businesses with many different product lines or those looking forward to expanding their range soon enough.

Branding and Customisation

Etsy: Standard but Sweet

Despite having plenty of templates and other customisation options, Etsy isn't the most flexible place ever regarding branding. Your shop will always have its own unique “Etsy” feel, which could be a good thing or not, depending on what you like.

Shopify: Branding Galore

On the other hand… If branding is your thing, look no further than Shopify, my friend! They offer a broad selection of themes, templates and customisation tools; you can create an online store where everything reflects the personality and aesthetics of your brand. From advanced design options to custom domains, with Shopify, many possibilities await all those creative minds!

Marketing and Discoverability

Etsy: A Multitude of Shoppers but Crowded Marketplace

Among Etsy's most significant selling points is its built-in colossal audience consisting of millions upon millions of potential customers worldwide who visit regularly looking forward to new things, discovering, buy try out, test driving, experiencing, wearing, enjoying, et cetera, et cetera (you get the point). So yeah, basically – lots of people see what sells here daily! But here's a catch: since tons of sellers compete against each other to get noticed among these sea shoppers, getting attention might sometimes be challenging.

Shopify: Requires Marketing Efforts

Now, when it comes down to Shopify… It's up to you to drive traffic, promote the store as effectively as possible, attract more visitors, convert them into buyers, retain loyal customers for life, etc. Yes, ladies, gentlemen, boys, girls, and pets, too – YOU HAVE ALL CONTROL OVER MARKETING EFFORTS WITH SHOPIFY. Their platform offers a range of powerful features and interact gradations that allow leverage of social media and many other ways to reach the different ways to read the best possible results within the shortest achieved within the shortest period available on planet Earth today (and probably tomorrow, too).

Pricing and Fees

Etsy: Fee Crazy

Regarding pricing structure alone, Etsy can sometimes be confusing because they nickel-dime sellers left, right, up, and down everywhere! There are listing fees, transaction fees, shipping fees, payment processing feed, advertising fees (optional)… and, oh, did I forget to mention any other hidden charges that might conveniently pop up just when I thought I knew about all of them? But don't worry – for most small businesses, these costs remain reasonable until the company starts growing exponentially, and then suddenly, one day, BAM! It feels like every penny that comes in goes out back the same way again but only multiplied by ten thousand times more.

👉 Read More:  Blogging: How to Write Blog Posts That Captivate and Convert

Shopify: Straightforward But Costly

Opposite to Etsy, Shopify has a simplified subscription pricing plan of $29 per month. It may appear costly initially, but it can save you money over time, particularly if you have a big business. Furthermore, the fees charged on transactions made through Shopify are lower than those charged by Etsy if you process your payments using their gateway.

The Nitty-Gritty Details

Ecommerce Mobile Payments Trend

Now, we need to cover the details. I'm talking about the little things that can make or break your decision.

Payment Processing

Etsy: Bare bones but integrated

On Etsy, you have to use their payment processing. This is great because it makes it easy for customers to check out, but bad because you can't use different payment gateways or negotiate rates.

Shopify: More options than you know what to do with

You can choose from many payment gateways with Shopify, including PayPal, Stripe, and more. This allows shopping for the best rate and features according to business needs.

Shipping and Fulfillment

Etsy: Good enough

Etsy has essential tools for printing labels, managing orders, and tracking shipments. These work well enough if you're a small seller sending things out occasionally. Still, they don't scale up as well as some other platforms' offerings if your business grows beyond that point or has any particular complexity in shipping requirements.

Shopify: Everything you ever wanted

Shopify has a suite of shipping and fulfilment tools built into the platform. They can scale up with your business from real-time carrier rates through inventory management automation order processing – whatever needs to be streamlined!

Analytics and Reporting

Etsy: Basic insights

Etsy provides sellers with simple analytics about views, orders, etc.. Still, if you want anything fancy or more advanced in data analysis, then unfortunately, third-party apps will be required here.

Shopify: Data-driven decisions

The data that Shopify's analytics and reporting capabilities provide could be described as second–to–-none when it comes down to making informed business decisions off them, detailed sales reports, customer behaviour analysis… You name it! If there's one thing that could potentially change the game entirely for those who know how to take advantage, this would be it!

App Integrations and Add-Ons

Etsy: Small but growing

Etsy may not have as many apps available in its ecosystem as other platforms like Shopify; however, there are still quite a few integrations and add-ons that can help streamline your selling processes – marketing tools or inventory management. Does anyone know?

Shopify: The possibilities are endless

When it comes to app stores, everyone knows that Shopify is one of the most extensive out there, with thousands upon thousands of different apps and integrations to choose from. So whether you need advanced SEO tools or want a dropshipping solution, this platform has your back.

Finding Your Niche and Target Audience

Types Of Target Audiences

The way to succeed on Etsy or Shopify is by finding your niche and understanding your target market. Doing this will enable you to create products, branding and marketing strategies that appeal best to them.

Etsy: Tapping into Passion Points

👉 Read More:  How Graphic Design Impacts Consumer's Perception of a Brand

Some sellers on Etsy are successful because they cater to particular interests or communities. For example, one might specialise in handcrafted jewellery designed for geeks and gamers. Another person may make customised pet accessories meant for proud fur parents only. In all these cases, tapping into such passion points establishes trust with followers who could have quickly passed by without noticing anything unique about your offering.

Shopify: Solving Problems or Fulfilling Desires

On Shopify, there are no limits to finding a suitable niche; however, many people choose one based on solving problems through providing innovative products/services or catering to specific interest groups/lifestyles, etc. For instance, consider setting up an online store that deals with sustainable fashion, where different types of eco-friendly clothes and matching accessories will be sold out to customers who are more concerned about environmental conservation while still looking good.

Regardless of your platform, be sure to do your homework! Conduct in-depth market research coupled with active social media involvement, among other things, to identify potential buyers and refine your business model until everything finally falls into place.

The Art of Product Photography and Listing Optimisation

Product Photo Editing Adidas Shoes

Everything in the world of online selling depends on visuals. Depending on high-quality product photography and compelling product descriptions, Etsy and Shopify can be a make-or-break stage for your sales success. 

Etsy: Stunning Snaps that Make You Stand Out

On Etsy, where competition is fierce, you have to have the best product photos to get noticed by buyers. Invest in good lighting, backgrounds, styling – whatever will make your products look their best! You should also optimise listings with relevant keywords and detailed descriptions (don't forget to add some personality, too!) so potential customers can find what they're looking for.

Shopify: Telling a Visual Story

With Shopify, the sky's the limit when creating an overall brand experience through product photography and website design. Consider getting professional shots or learning to take them yourself if you want more control over visually presenting your products. Combine these pictures with persuasive copywriting techniques such as using powerful words or storytelling methods, and ensure SEO optimisation so people not only buy but also share what they bought from others, improving both visibility and sales.

In ecommerce, everything is driven by looks; therefore, remember this if nothing else were true because beautiful shots combined with well-crafted listings may change someone who is just browsing into someone who keeps coming back again!

Building a Loyal Customer Base

Even though acquiring new customers is essential, having a solid and nurturing relationship with them is equally necessary. Such a strategy is crucial for long-term success in either Etsy or Shopify.

Etsy: Making Use of the Community

It is worth noting that Etsy boasts of having a lively community of sellers and buyers. It will help if you interact with your clients by answering their reviews, engaging in discussion forums, and sharing some behind-the-scene peeks into your creative process. This personal bond can promote loyalty among clients, making them buy from you again next time.

Shopify: Personalisation coupled with Rewards

👉 Read More:  Luxury Brand Marketing & High-End Branding

When using Shopify, there are multiple ways in which you can capitalise on tools and tactics to build customer loyalty. These include but are not limited to giving personalised product recommendations, introducing reward systems or loyalty programs, and keeping in touch via email marketing campaigns and social media platforms. Moreover, going the extra mile while providing excellent service could transform contented consumers into brand evangelists who will tell others about your enterprise.

Whatever platform one uses calls for continuous hard work, genuineness, and dedication to ensuring every client has an outstanding experience to establish a loyal customer base.

Staying Ahead of the Curve

Shopify Courses

Etsy: Accepting Trends and Innovation

On Etsy, it is essential to keep up with what is happening around you regarding new and emerging trends and shifts in consumer preferences to accommodate them for a better customer experience. One may follow popular hashtags, attend maker events (virtual or physical) or even diversify the products offered by introducing more creative items.

Shopify: Using Data and Automation

Shopify provides powerful analytics tools that enable them to understand how customers behave, sales patterns and areas where they need to improve. This information can be used when coming up with new products or services, marketing strategies, and other decisions relating to operations. In addition, automation tools should also be considered because they help simplify tasks, making it possible for an enterprise to proliferate without hiring more staff members.

Regardless of the chosen platform, curiosity, adaptability, and willingness to try different technologies and methods will ensure business survival amidst constant changes within the online selling industry.

The Verdict: Which One's Right for You?

Okay, we covered much ground, and you're ready to pick it up already. But wait a second, my friend — whether you should use Etsy or Shopify depends on your business needs and goals.

If you're a maker, crafter or vintage seller who wants a pre-built marketplace with its audience, Etsy could be perfect for you. It's easy to use and beginner-friendly with its supportive community vibe.

However, if you want more options in what kind of items can be sold online (flexibility), higher potential growth rates (scalability), and the ability to customise appearance without limits, look no further than Shopify; this platform is powerful! It offers robust features such as seamless integration abilities alongside vital marketing tools, making it great for those starting medium enterprises with big dreams concerning their future sales numbers or even larger companies seeking complete control over how their stores look on various devices, among other things.

Remember that only some things will work equally well for everyone, so some sellers may find value in being present across both sites to exploit different markets. 

Ultimately, the choice comes down to what matters most: time, effort, energy or money. Fear not, though, because regardless of which decision path gets chosen, endless opportunities are waiting online where people sell things – all one has to do is put themselves out there (and keep up with the times).

Wrapping Up: Choosing the Right Path

As we finish this journey through Etsy vs Shopify, we must remember there is no universal solution. The platform that works for you will depend on your specific business objectives, what products you sell, and your overall vision of things.

👉 Read More:  Brand Reputation Strategy: Building Trust and Loyalty

Etsy might be the best fit for you if you are a maker, crafter or vintage seller who wants to join a supportive community and use an existing market. Its easy-to-use interface and built-in customer base can give a good start to your online selling career.

On the other hand, if you need more options in terms of scalability and flexibility while selling various types of goods or services, then Shopify may be what you've been looking for in an e-commerce powerhouse. Its robust features, advanced marketing tools, and seamless integration potential provide everything needed to support growth plans and allow complete control over one's storefront online.

At the end of it all, though, which way should one go? Well, this decision will depend mainly upon where their priorities lie at any given moment, along with available resources plus long-term goals, among others – Who knows, they may even decide on taking up both these platforms simultaneously to benefit from each other's strengths thereby widening their revenue streams too.

Whichever path is chosen, always keep in mind that success does not come quickly when venturing into such kind of business; therefore, hard work coupled with consistency must be embraced wholeheartedly throughout this process while learning from past failures should also remain part parcel till eventually striving towards giving customers nothing short but excellent service becomes second nature.

In conclusion, my dear friend, do not fear entering the digital market. Instead, embrace it with open arms, knowing that people can quickly want what they cannot have. Hence, once supply meets demand, the sky becomes the limit for any entrepreneur like yourself who possesses the necessary drive backed up by proper knowledge, skills and attitude required to succeed, thus making online ventures thrive beyond anyone's imagination.


Can I sell on both Etsy and Shopify?

Of course! Many sellers operate on both platforms because it allows them to reach more customers and increase their chances of making a sale. You need to keep your inventory synchronised and ensure that the product listings are updated across all platforms not to confuse buyers or oversell.

What's the cost of setting up an account with Etsy or Shopify?

For each item you list, Etsy charges $0.20 as a listing fee; transaction fees ranging between 5% and 15% apply depending on the item's price. Conversely, Shopify has different monthly subscription plans starting from $29; there is also a transaction fee for using external payment gateways.

Do I have to be a professional seller or own a business license before using these platforms?

No, this is not mandatory. Both Etsy and Shopify were designed for various types of sellers, including individuals who sell things as hobbies or side jobs, as well as established businesses. However, it would be wise to research local laws applicable to your industry.

Can I sell digital products/services on Etsy?

How do I know which pricing plan is appropriate for my needs when signing up for Shopify?

Monthly subscription fees range between $29 (Basic) and $299 (Advanced), depending on the number of staff accounts required by monthly sales volume, advanced features needed, etc.

Can we change the appearance/design aspects for online stores hosted by Etsy or Shopify?

With regards to appearance options: While offering pre-designed templates plus limited customisation alternatives, with themes plus customisation tools, one can have more flexibility/control over branding/designing their store through Shopify than Etsy provides

Which marketing strategies work best for driving traffic to my Shopify store or Etsy?

For Etsy, using relevant keywords within product descriptions, titles, tags, etc., engaging with the community and harnessing the power of social media can prove effective in driving traffic. On the other hand, Shopify has built-in marketing tools like SEO optimisation, email campaigns, and partnerships with influencers; they also provide paid ads management services.

How should I handle shipping/fulfilment on these platforms?

The essential shipping/fulfilment tools Etsy provides suit most users. Still, Shopify offers more advanced features such as real-time carrier rate calculation, inventory management systems or automated order processing options.

If I switch platforms, can I transfer my Etsy shop to Shopify (or vice versa)?

Although possible, complex processes requiring third-party tools/services may be necessary to migrate products/data from one platform to another.

Photo of author

Stuart Crawford

Stuart Crawford is an award-winning creative director and brand strategist with over 15 years of experience building memorable and influential brands. As Creative Director at Inkbot Design, a leading branding agency, Stuart oversees all creative projects and ensures each client receives a customised brand strategy and visual identity.

Need help Building your Brand?

Let’s talk about your logo, branding or web development project today! Get in touch for a free quote.

Leave a Comment

Trusted by Businesses Worldwide to Create Impactful and Memorable Brands

At Inkbot Design, we understand the importance of brand identity in today's competitive marketplace. With our team of experienced designers and marketing professionals, we are dedicated to creating custom solutions that elevate your brand and leave a lasting impression on your target audience.