Snapchat vs TikTok (Forget the Hype, Focus on What Works)

Snapchat vs TikTok (Forget the Hype, Focus on What Works)

Most small business owners and entrepreneurs I talk to feel this immense pressure. A pressure to be everywhere, all at once. TikTok’s exploding. Snapchat’s still got a user base. “If I’m not on there, I’m missing out!”

The biggest missing piece for most isn't another platform. It's a coherent strategy for the platforms they're already on. Or, even more fundamentally, a clear understanding of who they’re trying to reach and what they want them to do.

“Be everywhere” is terrible advice. Be strategic.

The “be everywhere” mantra is a fast track to burnout and diluted effort. It’s advice peddled by those who don’t understand the value of focus. Or your sanity.

Your time, your money, your creative energy – these are finite. Pouring them thinly across a dozen platforms means you’re unlikely to make a real impact on any of them.

It's not about presence; it's about impact.

Defining your audience first (not the platform's)

Before you even glance at the download button for Snapchat or TikTok, answer this: Who is your ideal customer?

• How old are they?
• What are their genuine interests (not the ones you think they have)?
• Where do they actually spend their time online seeking information or entertainment?
• What kind of content genuinely resonates with them, makes them stop scrolling?

If your ideal customer is a 55-year-old CEO looking for B2B software solutions, then frankly, agonising over TikTok dances is probably a monumental waste of your time. Sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many miss this.

Snapchat: What’s the Real Deal for Business in 2025?

Snapchat. It’s still around. It’s not the behemoth it once was in terms of cultural dominance, but it retains a dedicated, if specific, user base.

• Ephemeral nature: Strength or weakness? Content that disappears. This was Snapchat's original hook. For users, it encourages less performative, more “in-the-moment” sharing. For businesses? It means a constant content treadmill. Your brilliant Snap is gone in 24 hours. Poof. This can create urgency, sure. But it can also be a relentless demand.
  
• Key demographics: Who’s actually still snapping? While it started very young, its core demographic has aged up slightly. Think late teens to mid-twenties primarily, with a decent showing in the 25-34 bracket. Globally, Statista data from early 2024 showed a strong concentration of users under 35. If your audience is firmly older than that, tread very carefully. It’s not a ghost town, but it’s a specific neighbourhood.
  
• Core features for business – a quick, no-fluff rundown.
  
  • Snaps & Stories: Your basic disappearing photos and videos.
  • Lenses (AR Filters): Augmented reality overlays. Can be fun, can be brand-relevant, can be expensive to develop custom ones.
  • Filters: Geographic or event-based static overlays.
  • Ads: Various formats, from video ads to promoted Lenses.
  • Discover: Content from publishers and select creators. Getting featured here is a long shot for most small businesses.

Where Snapchat Might Shine for Entrepreneurs

Let's not dismiss it entirely. There are niches.

• Hyper-local engagement: Geofilters can be surprisingly effective (and cheap) for businesses with physical locations targeting local events or areas. A coffee shop offering a cool filter for a local festival? Smart.
• Behind-the-scenes rawness: If your brand thrives on unpolished, immediate, “day-in-the-life” content, Snapchat’s fleeting nature can feel authentic. Think of a solo artisan, a personal trainer. It has to feel real, though. “Forced rawness is just awkward.”
• AR Lenses for niche product interaction: This is more advanced. If you sell something where an AR “try-on” makes sense (cosmetics, accessories), a custom Lens could be innovative. But budget accordingly – this isn’t a DIY job for most.

The Downsides: Why Snapchat Could Be a Time Sink

Now for the cold water.

• “It feels like a closed garden.” Discovery challenges. Snapchat is not built for casual discovery in the same way TikTok is. It’s more about connecting with people you already know, or brands you actively seek out. Gaining new followers organically is a slog. A real slog.
• Content creation demands constant churn. That ephemeral content needs constant replacement. If you’re a one-person marketing department (i.e., you, the business owner), is this really the best use of your precious hours?
• Measuring actual ROI: Can you genuinely track sales from Snaps? Attribution can be murky. Sure, you can track swipe-ups if you have that feature (often requiring a certain ad spend or follower count). But linking a Snap Story view to a sale three weeks later? Good luck. “Vanity metrics like views are nice, but they don't pay the mortgage.”

Snapchat Ads: Worth the Punt?

The ad platform is there. You can target by demographics, interests, and location.

• Ad formats and targeting: Video ads, filter ads, AR lens ads. The targeting options are reasonably granular.
  
• Cost considerations for small budgets: You can start with a small budget. But like any ad platform, effectiveness often scales with spend and skilled optimisation. Is your £50 better spent here or on a platform with clearer conversion paths for your specific business?
  
• “Is anyone really clicking and buying from Snapchat ads?” A hard look. Some do, for specific types of products – impulse buys, youth-focused brands, and entertainment. For a local accountant? Probably not your prime lead source. The intent on Snapchat is often more social browsing than active shopping.
  
  One business owner I know with a custom t-shirt side-hustle tried Snapchat ads. He got views. He got a few clicks. He got precisely zero attributable sales after a £200 spend. His take? “Felt like shouting into a very specific, very young void.”
  

TikTok: The Juggernaut – But is it Your Juggernaut?

Ah, TikTok. The algorithmically-driven, dopamine-dispensing, trend-generating monster. You can’t ignore its scale. But you can question if it's right for you.

• The algorithm: “The For You Page” (FYP) addiction machine. TikTok’s FYP is legendary for its ability to learn what you like and feed you an endless stream. This means your content, if it hits the right notes, could be seen by a vast number of people who don’t follow you. That’s the carrot. The stick? You’re at the mercy of an ever-changing, secret algorithm.
• Demographics: Broader than you think, but still strong youth lean. Yes, it started with Gen Z. But older demographics are on TikTok. You'll find gardeners, chefs, lawyers, accountants (yes, really). However, the dominant user base and the general vibe still skew younger and more trend-driven. According to a late 2023 report by Ofcom, it's the go-to for news for many UK teens. Think about that. News. On TikTok.
• Content style: Authenticity (or the appearance of it), trends, education-as-entertainment. Overly polished, corporate content usually dies a swift death. Users crave perceived authenticity, humour, value delivered quickly, and, of course, content that taps into current trends (sounds, formats, challenges). “Edu-tainment” is a big one – teaching something useful in an engaging, fast-paced way.

TikTok’s Seductive Pull for Businesses

The allure is undeniable.

• Potential for massive organic reach (the viral lottery). This is the big one. One video can get millions of views without you spending a penny on ads. It's rare, like winning a scratch card, but it happens. And that potential keeps people hooked.
• User-generated content (UGC) goldmine (if you can spark it). Encouraging users to create content featuring your product or brand can be incredibly powerful. Think of challenges or using a specific sound linked to your brand. It’s authentic social proof.
• Showcasing personality and brand voice effectively. TikTok allows for, and almost demands, more personality than many other platforms. If your brand has a quirky, human side, this is where it can shine.
• TikTok Shop / E-commerce integrations: The new frontier? This is evolving rapidly. The ability to tag products and allow users to buy directly within the app is a potential game-changer for e-commerce businesses. Early days for many, but the direction of travel is clear: social commerce.

The Pitfalls: Why TikTok Might Derail Your Focus

But here’s the other side of the coin.

• Trend chasing: A full-time job that distracts from core business. New trends emerge daily. Hourly, even. Trying to keep up can be exhausting and pull you away from, you know, actually running your business. And jumping on a trend late, or badly, is just cringeworthy. “There's nothing sadder than a corporate dad trying to floss.”
• “Viral fame doesn't equal fortune.” The conversion challenge. Great, your video got a million views. How many of those translated into leads or sales? Often, far fewer than you’d hope. Virality without a clear path to conversion is just an ego boost.
• Content quality vs. quantity: The algorithm demands feeding. TikTok tends to reward consistent posting. This can lead to pressure to churn out content, sometimes at the expense of quality or strategic alignment.
• Brand reputation risks: One wrong move… The informal, fast-moving nature of TikTok also means it’s easier to misstep. A poorly judged attempt at humour or a trend can backfire spectacularly. The internet mob is swift and unforgiving.

TikTok Ads: Gambling or Smart Investment?

The ad platform is robust, with sophisticated targeting.

• Ad formats (In-Feed, TopView, Branded Effects). Plenty of options, from standard in-feed video ads to a premium TopView ad (the first thing users see when they open the app), and branded hashtag challenges or effects.
  
• Costs and bidding – can small players compete? You can get started with smaller budgets for in-feed ads. But for the big, impactful stuff like Branded Hashtag Challenges, you’re talking serious money. Competition is also increasing, which inevitably drives up costs.
  
• Attribution: “Did that dance challenge really sell my accounting software?” Like Snapchat, directly attributing sales from organic TikTok content can be tricky. Ads offer better tracking, but the journey from seeing a funny video to signing up for a serious B2B service can be long and winding. It's often more about top-of-funnel awareness.
  
  A small bakery owner I know tried TikTok. She spent hours making cute videos of her cakes. Some got decent views. She even got one with 50,000 views – “went mini-viral,” she said. Sales impact? Negligible. Her local Facebook group and email list still drove 90% of her orders. Her lesson: “The TikTok crowd liked looking. My locals liked buying.”
  

Head-to-Head: Snapchat vs TikTok – The Brutal Breakdown

Let's put them side-by-side, no punches pulled.

Audience & Demographics: Where Does Your Customer Live?

This is the absolute crux.

“If your audience isn't actively and meaningfully on one of these platforms, you're just shouting into the wind.”

Content Creation: Effort, Style, and Lifespan

• Snapchat:
  • Effort: Can be low (quick snap), but consistency is key. AR Lenses are high effort.
  • Style: Raw, unpolished, “in-the-moment.”
  • Lifespan: 24 hours for Stories (mostly). Fleeting.
• TikTok:
  • Effort: Can vary. A simple “talking head” can work, but trend-based/edited videos take more time. High consistency is often rewarded.
  • Style: “Authentic” (even if staged), engaging, often trend-driven, sound-on crucial.
  • Lifespan: Can be short if tied to a fast trend. It can have a longer tail if it hits the FYP sweet spot or offers evergreen value.

Organic Reach Potential: Myth vs. Reality

• Snapchat: Low for broad, new discovery. Good for deepening existing connections if they already follow you. “It's a conversation, not a broadcast to strangers.”
• TikTok: Potentially massive, algorithmically driven. The “viral lottery” is real, but don't bank your business on it. Highly unpredictable.

Advertising Platforms: Bang for Your Buck?

• Snapchat Ads: Can be effective for highly targeted youth demographics or location-based campaigns. Potentially lower competition in some niches means potentially lower costs. But measure carefully.
• TikTok Ads: Wider reach, high engagement potential. Costs are rising. Great for brand awareness. Direct response can work for e-commerce, but requires smart, creative and funnels. “Test, test, test. And then test again.”

Business Objectives Match-Up:

Let’s be blunt about what they’re realistically good for:

• Brand Awareness:
  • TikTok: High potential if content resonates.
  • Snapchat: More niche, less broad awareness.
• Lead Generation:
  • TikTok: Possible with clever CTAs and funnels (e.g., to a lead magnet). Harder work.
  • Snapchat: Very challenging for most B2B/service businesses. Better for immediate local offers.
• Direct Sales/E-commerce:
  • TikTok: Increasingly strong with TikTok Shop and product linking. The future here looks promising for product-based businesses.
  • Snapchat: More limited, though some direct response can work for impulse-buy items.
• Community Building:
  • TikTok: Yes, through comments, duets, and stitches. Can build a loyal following.
  • Snapchat: More about private, smaller group interactions. Less of a broad “community” feel for brands.

Neither platform is a silver bullet for sales. They are primarily attention platforms. What you do with that attention is what matters.

“So, Which One Do I Pick?” – The Annoying but Honest Answer

You're probably hoping I'll just say “pick TikTok” or “Snapchat's your secret weapon.” Sorry. That's not how this works.

It’s Not About the Platform, It’s About You.

The right choice depends entirely on:

• Your business type:
  • Selling quirky t-shirts to 20-somethings? TikTok might be your playground.
  • Offering high-value B2B consultancy? Probably neither, frankly. Or at least, they’d be very low on your priority list.
  • Local cafe wanting to drive footfall? Snapchat geofilters could be a cheap experiment. TikTok showing your atmosphere could work.
• Your resources:
  • Time: Do you genuinely have the hours to dedicate to creating native content consistently for these platforms? Be honest.
  • Budget: Can you afford to experiment with ads? Can you afford to hire someone if you can’t do it yourself?
  • Creative capacity: Are you, or is someone on your team, naturally inclined to create the type of short, snappy, engaging video content these platforms devour? “If you hate being on camera and can't string two words together, video platforms are going to be painful.”
• Your brand personality:
  • Is your brand serious, formal, or traditional? Trying to force it into TikTok trends might look deeply inauthentic.
  • Is your brand playful, human, a bit irreverent? You might feel right at home.

The “Neither” Option: Is It Okay to Sit These Out?

Absolutely. Yes. 100%.

It’s not just okay; sometimes it's the smartest move.

• Focusing on what already works: If you have marketing channels that are already delivering results (email, SEO, LinkedIn, whatever), doubling down on those might be a far better use of your resources than chasing the shiny new thing.
• Alternative platforms: Are there other, perhaps less “sexy” but more effective, platforms for your niche? Pinterest for visual products? LinkedIn for B2B? Good old-fashioned Google Ads?
• “The fear of missing out (FOMO) is a terrible business strategist.” Making decisions based on FOMO is a recipe for wasted effort. Make decisions based on data, on a clear understanding of your audience, and on your strategic objectives.

Testing the Waters Without Drowning

If you do decide one (or both) might be worth exploring:

• Small, measurable experiments: Don’t go all-in. Dedicate a small, fixed amount of time and/or budget.
• Define success before you start: What does a “win” look like for this experiment? X number of website clicks? Y number of genuine enquiries (not just views)? Z level of engagement from your target demographic?
• Don't be afraid to cut your losses: If, after a fair trial period, it’s not delivering, walk away. Seriously. There's no shame in saying, “This isn't for us.” It's smart.

Practical Advice (If You’re Still Determined to Dive In)

Alright, so you’re still keen. You believe there’s potential. Fair enough. Here’s how to approach it without looking like a total amateur.

For Snapchat:

• Focus on intimacy and exclusivity. Think “insider access.”
• Leverage local if it applies. Geofilters for events, specific locations.
• Experiment with AR if you have a genuine use case and budget. Don't just do it because it looks cool. Does it add value or solve a problem for your customer (e.g., virtual try-on)?
• “Don't expect miracles. Expect niche engagement, maybe.” Manage your expectations.

For TikTok:

• Understand trends, but don’t be a slave to them. How can you adapt a trend to fit your brand and message, rather than just copying it blindly? Originality within a trend often performs well.
• Authenticity and relatability are key. Lose the corporate speak. Be human. Show your face. Share your actual personality (or your brand's).
• Educate, entertain, or inspire. Preferably all three. This is a good mantra for TikTok content. Provide value in a digestible, engaging way.
• Engage with comments and build community. Reply to comments. Ask questions. Foster interaction. The algorithm notices this.

Cross-Platform Wisdom (That Actually Works)

This applies whether you use these platforms or others.

• Repurposing content smartly. This doesn’t mean blasting the exact same video everywhere. Adapt it for the nuances of each platform. A TikTok video might need different text overlays or a different call to action if used as an Instagram Reel or YouTube Short.
• Driving traffic to your own assets. This is critical. Use these platforms to drive people to your website, your email list, and your product pages. Don’t build your entire house on rented land. Algorithms change, and platforms can ban you. Owning your audience connection is paramount. (If you need a hand figuring out how to make your digital marketing actually drive to your assets, that's something we at Inkbot Design drill down on: Inkbot Design Digital Marketing Services)
• Consistent branding, even in short-form chaos. Your brand voice, your visual cues (where possible), should still be recognisable.

Final Kick Up the Arse: Stop Agonising, Start Strategising

Look, the debate of Snapchat vs TikTok can go on forever in marketing circles. For you, the entrepreneur, the small business owner, it’s simpler.

Analysis paralysis is your enemy.

Spending weeks mulling this over is time you could be spending on action.

Pick one (or none), test, learn, adapt.

If there's a genuine hypothesis that one of these platforms could work for your specific business and audience, then devise a small, controlled experiment. If not, focus elsewhere.

Focus on genuine connection and value, not just noise.

Whichever platform you use, aim to be a signal, not just more noise. Provide real value. Engage authentically.

“The ‘best' platform is the one that brings you actual business, not just digital back-pats.”

Forget vanity metrics. Focus on what moves the needle for your business. Leads. Sales. Loyal customers.

Conclusion: The Real Winner is Strategy, Not a Platform

So, Snapchat or TikTok? The blunt truth is, the platform itself is a secondary concern. Your strategy, your deep understanding of your specific audience, and your commitment to creating genuinely relevant and engaging content – those are primary.

Don't get suckered into the hype cycle or feel pressured to be on a platform just because “everyone else is.” They aren't, and even if they were, your business isn't “everyone else's.”

Make a cold, hard, analytical decision based on your unique business needs, your resources, and crucially, where your ideal customers actually spend their time and attention.

If a platform doesn’t scream “hell yes, this is a perfect fit for us and we can commit to doing it well,” then a “hell no,” or even a “not right now,” is an incredibly smart, and often profitable, answer. Focus wins.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions):

Feeling clearer, or perhaps more confused than ever, about where to point your marketing cannon? That’s common. The digital world is noisy

If you’re tired of the fluff and want straight-talking advice on how your business can actually make sense of digital marketing – whether that involves TikTok, Snapchat, or more likely, the stuff that really builds a foundation – then perhaps we should talk.

Explore what a more strategic approach looks like at Inkbot Design's Digital Marketing Services.

Or, if you’ve got a specific project in mind and want to cut to the chase, request a quote and let’s see if we’re a fit.

Want more no-nonsense observations? Keep an eye on our blog. We’re not afraid to say what others only think.